All tools

Detailed Collection Value

Local game store

Cash or store credit

Roughest estimate
Typical return
About 25% to 60% in cash, or 35% to 75% in store credit, for cards of $5 or more.
Speed
The same day to two weeks.
Good
Fast and local, with no shipping.
Watch for
The lowest cash rate, and every store sets its own rates. Bulk is often refused.

Online vendors

For example Card Kingdom, CoolStuffInc and Star City Games

Typical return
About 55% to 70% in cash, or 70% to 90% in store credit, for cards of $5 or more.
Speed
Paid within days of grading.
Good
You know the price before you ship.
Watch for
You pay postage and carry the risk of loss. Grading can lower the total, vendors skip cards they have enough of, and bulk buying is limited.

Online marketplace

For example ManaPool

Typical return
Sellers typically keep about 80% to 92% of the sale price for cards of $5 or more, after fees and postage.
Speed
Slow for a large collection.
Good
The most money, at a price you set.
Watch for
The most work: listing, packing and shipping each order within two business days. Unsold cards stay unsold.
Sell on ManaPool

Bulk

Cards under $1.00 are bulk. Buyers usually pay for them per card or per 1,000, for example $10 per 1,000 commons and uncommons at CoolStuffInc in October 2026.

Store credit

Store credit is spent at the buyer's own prices, which run above market.

Other ways

Selling to players directly has no fees, but buyers usually expect 10% to 30% off and you carry the trust and safety risk. A collection service sells for you at about vendor rates, less a fee of about 2% to 10%.

How To Sell Your Magic: The Gathering Cards Tolarian Community College · 25:39

Sign in to see what your collection is worth.

Sign in